Sure to be a great hit!
Image source: http://www.realsimple.com
After the game is over, take down the pictures and hang up cute baby items such as onesies and socks, as the gifts are unwrapped.
Image source: http://factorydirectcraft.com
If you like, decorate the clothespins to match your theme or colour scheme with strips of decorative paper, japanese decorative tape, paint or stickers.
I love this idea, I'll be sure to try this one out.